Interesting story, poor pronunciation

Unfortunate mispronunciation of lots of things, but a good story nevertheless. Worth a listen I think.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A kind, well-researched account.

The production of this one is a bit patchy, but the voice is good and the amount of research that the author has put into it is delightful. It puts me in mind of the good old-fashioned journalism rather than the opinion pieces we overdose on now.

The author does his best to give a balanced account yet he clearly has a sympathy for the autistic bank robber. He tries to balance that with the recognition of the effects the robberies have on the victims but … well at least he tries.

I am a psychologist so I found it particularly interesting and I think people with at least a passing interest in mental health will enjoy the book most, but it is altogether interesting and accessible.

Probably a bit mean not to give it five stars, I did enjoy it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An interesting story

After deciding to take a gamble in this book I was glad that I did. A very interesting story well written and narrated. A few editing issues I thought, which makes it seem like there are two narrators tag teaming their way through the story, but it doesn't distract from the narrative. All in all very enjoyable.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Jumps about

Its a good story but the timeline jumps around so its hard to follow at times.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A great story let down by a poor audio performance

This is a fascinating story which is let down by this audio recording. There are two narrators - or it is the same narrator but recorded at different times (as a result it feels like two different people). The second voice (which is noticeably different to the main narrator) interjects with a sentence here and there, with the effect of jarring you out of the experience of listening. There are times where the second voice even sound like it is computer generated. It really makes it difficult to listen to and spoils the enjoyment of this audio book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Very enjoyable

I really enjoyed this - good narration, fascinating story.

Minor criticisms: Early on I found the jumping around in time quite irritating until I settled into it, and there is a little bit too much information given about the global financial crisis given how little it relates directly to the story - we don't need to know all about CDOs and money markets to understand this story, or that there was widespread anger about the banks and the behaviours of bankers at the time Jackley was active. I think these passages could have either been omitted or condensed since they felt like distractions from the story proper.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Found it very hard to listen to. Narrator rubbish.

This isn’t a drama it’s an account of real events - so the accents and ‘voices” were not necessary, I found them very distracting.
The story is very padded out.
Did not enjoy it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

What a fantastic and fascinating listen

I’m so pleased that I chose to listen to this book whilst on my daily dog walking duties over the past week. The construction of the storyline had me riveted and eagerly looking forward to where, and how, we were going next. Ben Machell you’ve written a superb true story about a very intricate, interesting yet extremely troubled young man.
I worked in law enforcement for 35 yrs, the majority of which was spent hunting down and locking up the bad guys. Very early on in career I remember a Senior Detective telling me that no two criminal minds think the same or are the same. How true that was for me and how true for the investigators who were trying to identify Stephen Jackley.
Excellently narrated by David Linski.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Spoilt by Narration

It appears the narrator had to re-record a large portion of this book and his voice and audio quality is different. When this changes mid-sentence it is very off putting.

The story itself is interesting but could have been covered in an hour or maybe two without ten hours of filler.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not what it said on the tin.

In the interest of disclosure I should be clear that I did not finish this book.

It was initially annoying that the audio production was so poor. Whoever was responsible for the recording should have their head in shame - the different recording sessions - including added passages - where recorded in a way that made it so obvious that they were recorded at different times and at times even sounded like a different voice.

The book itself was very disappointing in that the story of the crimes plays a minor part and takes a back seat to the description and analysis of the boys life and motivations.
It should be made clear in the description that this is the case as the strap line suggests.
It’s not a crime novel in fact it’s not a novel at all (possibly my mistake).
It’s an account of mental health issues and their impact on an individual.
Possibly an important document, but not what I thought I was buying.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!