The Malvern Mystery

I found I couldn't get into the book after a body was found.
The book cover did not match the year/century the story was in. That might be a small thing but the images I had in my head did not match the things that was said in the book. It didn't feel like we were in the 19th century. This could be just me.
Later in the book it gets more interesting as they try and find out who donit.
This is my personal opinion and others might disagree with me and actually love it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An easy listen

I enjoyed the adventures of Lorna and Margaret very much, the narrator set the scene perfectly and the twists and turns left me guessing until the very end.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great listen

Great book with a even better narrator, thoroughly enjoyed it !
Couldn't stop listening, highly recommended

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent, easy listen

This was a most enjoyable listen. When a book moves to audio it is the narrator that makes the book or kills the vibe. This narrator is perfect for this novel because she brings it alive with a voice that sounds just right for the story.
Being based in an area of the country I don't know and in a year I know very little about, this was a good education for me as well as a good listen. I leaned a lot and hope that the research was accurate, because I believed it all.
The story is well written; I can see this as a film, such is the high quality of the narrator with the writer's words.
I enjoyed trying to guess who was guilty and who would be innocent. The red herrings are out in force and I didn't guess the final team event until presented with the facts.
I will look for more work by this writer and narrator. Most enjoyable! This investigating team has many more stories in them.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not for the historical purists but I liked it.

This is an easy book to listen to. The story is well paced and the main characters are easily distinguishable. The narrative is a fairly straight forward whodunnit on a background of superstition and country ways, a fear of the pagan and of the local navvies and an outsider in the form of Lorna Buchanan who is her own woman and cuts through the flimflam.
The historical setting doesn't really gel with the character of Lorna or Margaret or most of the other women to be honest. They seem too modern despite the belief in the power of the sacred and old druidic ways. I did like the navvies wives and their down-to-earth ways.
However despite the anachronistic feel I liked this story, I liked the way Lorna's backstory is interwoven, describing some of her experiences in India, her home but not home.
I liked the narrator too. There were one or two minor production issues, repeated words or phrases but it didn't ruin the enjoyment.
I will look out for more from this author

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great Murder Mystery

This isnt my usual genre, most of the books I listen to/read are set in modern times, but I'm loving the mystery/thriller genre at the moment and thought I'd give this a try as it sounded intriguing.

I'm so glad I did. I really enjoyed it. Lorna is a great main character, she's clever, witty and very ahead of her time, which I loved. Other people's reactions to her are sometimes funny, I could totally see her at the front of women's movements if set at a different time. All the characters were believable, some loveable some totally not. The novel is what I think of as a 'Miss Marple Mystery,' quite slow paced (in a good way, not dead bodies every few pages), quaint, village feel, mystery. I really enjoyed it and would definitely recommend. It was left open to have a sequel, and I really hope that happens.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Intriguing

An intriguing tale. It took me a little while to settle into the flow of the story but I am glad I persevered. Lorna Buchanan’s short time as a teacher at St Anne’s College in Malvern soon leads to a murder investigation. Set in 19th century this is an entertaining historical murder mystery.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Old Fashion Whodunit

This is meant to be the 19th century but the feeling is earlier, but a lovely listen just the same no hard concentration needed Sarah Buchanan fresh from India where she mainly grew up as her father was stationed there so she has picked up a few useful Indian traits and they showed up in this story. She is a schoolteacher and has a trouble maker student Margaret but Margaret is not in with the crowd so basically she is lonely for the same attention that the other girls get so she slips out one night to see what is going on, and Sarah realizes it and goes after her. She finds her but at the same time, they witness some strange goings-on and Margaret insist it's the Druid back again but Sarah thinks not, but she got Margaret back no harm done, but the headmistress finds out and knows better and wanted to know why she was not informed of Margaret taking off at night as its forbidden Sarah says she had it under control but nonetheless she gets the sack and as soon as she is gone Margaret gets expelled. There is a murder and the school's benefactor shows up and asks Sarah to look into it. This plods along nicely and the characters are portrayed very well and the narrator Melanie Crawley does an excellent job and it's really worth a listen.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Cozy Mystery

This book is what I would describe as a 'cozy mystery'. It had loads of great elements - the historical setting, strong female characters, folkloric themes. The story moved at a very comfortable pace and it was easy to listen to.

It won't change your life, and there are certainly parts of it that jar a bit (the aforementioned strong female characters get away with a lot more than is believable, given the book is set in 1859), and it's a bit shallow with some of the characters and the folklore elements, but I think it reads the way it was meant to be read - nothing heavy.

The narration is very good.

A good book for a holiday!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Enjoyable listen

I am a fan of stories with a similar vein to Sherlock Holmes, and this didn't disappoint. A well written story with twists and turns that kept me guessing till the end!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!