Send us a text

We wander into the shadowy streets of Aliquippa, peeling back layers of intrigue surrounding the unresolved murder of Rachel Del Tonto. Her story, tangled with wealth, broken engagements, and mysterious liaisons, paints a picture of love gone wrong in a town steeped in history and danger. The shocking end of her engagement to Frank Catroppa, known as "the Wolf of Aliquippa," and the chain of events that would ultimately lead to her tragic demise. Through the lens of small-town dynamics and police missteps, we lay bare the complexities that continue to shroud her murder in mystery.

Timeline: The Murder Of Rachael DelTondo - BeaverCountian.com
Rachael DelTondo Murder: Beaver County DA names prime suspect – WPXI

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music

Send us a text

What if the entertainment industry’s biggest names are hiding sinister secrets? Join us on "What We Lose in the Shadows" as Caroline and I unpack the shocking arrest of P Diddy, who faces charges of trafficking, sexual abuse, and RICO violations in Manhattan. We delve into the disturbing allegations, including a heinous incident with Cassie in a hotel hallway, and question the implications of his powerful Hollywood connections. The whispers involving other celebrities like J-Lo, Justin Bieber, and Usher add a chilling dimension, forcing us to confront the harsh realities of how the entertainment industry treats its most vulnerable members.

Switching gears, we examine the heartbreaking disappearance of 13-year-old Madeline Soto. The conflicting accounts from her parents, Jennifer Soto and Stephan Sterns, cast a pall of suspicion over the case. Stephan’s behavior, like resetting his phone before the police could investigate, raises red flags that point to a darker truth. We scrutinize the complex web of lies and denial, comparing it to infamous cases like JonBenet Ramsey. The episode closes on a somber note as we discuss the potential complicity of Jennifer and the gut-wrenching implications of child abuse, trafficking, and the search for justice in such tragic circumstances.

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music

Send us a text

Could a trusted figure of authority exploit their power to commit unthinkable crimes? That's the chilling question we unravel as we kick off this episode of "What We Lose in the Shadows. Today we navigate the devastating case of Sandra Birchmore, a young girl with aspirations for a career in law enforcement, whose life was tragically cut short. Prepare for a gripping discussion that includes trigger warnings for grooming, trafficking, and murder, focusing on the disturbing actions of Detective Matthew Farwell and the ongoing quest for justice by Sandra's family and Dr. Michael Baden.

Follow us on Instagram at "What We Lose in the Shadows" to stay informed on this ongoing case and share your thoughts. Join us next Tuesday as we return to explore another harrowing tale that lurks in the shadows.

Former Officer Charged With Killing Sandra Birchmore, Whose Death Was Ruled a Suicide - The New York Times (nytimes.com)

Sandra Birchmore's family files suit against 3 ex-Stoughton police officers (boston.com)

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music

Send us a text

Ever wondered how a seemingly lighthearted conversation can segue into a discussion on the gravest aspects of political life? This episode promises to take you on such a journey, starting with our playful chatter about autumn and a hilarious story of an Australian break dancer whose name is a perfect match for her moves. But the mood soon intensifies as we delve into the attempted assassination of Donald Trump by Thomas Matthew Crooks, dissecting the security protocols at the Pennsylvania rally and examining the historical and moral implications of political violence in a democracy.

How does ego and entitlement disrupt our political conversations? We grapple with this question as we reflect on the importance of civil discourse in our society. From reminiscing about the days when politics and religion were taboo at family dinners to assessing the tragic consequences of political violence, we provide a thoughtful analysis on the state of political dialogue today. We also delve into the contentious debate over gun control, contrasting hunting rifles and assault-style weapons, and emphasize the necessity of maintaining a mature, peaceful democracy.

Trump's close call: A detailed time line : NPR
What to Know About the Assassination Attempt on Trump - The New York Times (nytimes.com)

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music

Send us a text

In this episode, we navigate through the heinous acts committed by Wade Wilson in 2019, shedding light on his disturbing murders in Fort Myers. We delve into the heart-wrenching confession to his father and the moral quandaries faced during his testimony. Additionally, the episode exposes the troubling mishandling of a survivor's assault case, which foreshadowed Wilson's crimes. Through this discourse, we confront the broader issues within the justice system, the nuances of consent, and the contentious debate over capital punishment. Join us as we tackle these heavy topics with empathy and critical insight, aiming to foster a deeper understanding of these complex issues.

https://people.com/wade-wilson-murdered-women-inside-case-murderer-crimes-8683634
https://www.news-press.com/story/news/crime/2024/07/08/wade-wilson-murders-florida-killer-arrest-steve-testasecca/74308734007/
https://www.fox4now.com/news/local-news/lee-county/not-staying-silent-ex-girlfriend-of-wade-wilson-speaks-on-her-reported-attack

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music

Send us a text

What if the quiet neighborhoods of Visalia were hiding a dark secret? Join us as we unravel the chilling chronicles of California’s most infamous criminals in our latest episode of "What We Lose in the Shadows." We begin with a casual chat about the blistering heat in the Northeast and the delightful climate of San Diego—perfect for the American Library Association's conference. Caroline and I emphasize the importance of staying hydrated before we shift gears to discuss the notorious rise of crime in 1970s Visalia. Uncover the eerie transformation of the Cordova cat burglar into the East area rapist and beyond.

Prepare to be gripped by the harrowing accounts of those who survived the terror of the East Area Rapist, later unmasked as the Golden State Killer. Hear the stories of Phyllis Henneman and Jane Carson Sandler, whose courage and resilience in the face of unimaginable horrors are truly inspiring. We also highlight the pivotal role of true crime writer Michelle McNamara in bringing national attention to this case, which tragically ended with her passing in 2016. Finally, discover how detective Paul Holes used groundbreaking DNA technology to crack a case that had haunted California for decades. This episode promises a compelling exploration of criminal minds, the enduring spirit of survivors, and the relentless pursuit of justice.

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music

Send us a text

Can you imagine the horror of losing loved ones due to someone's reckless behavior? Brace yourself as we uncover the devastating case of Rebecca Grossman, a wealthy socialite who took the lives of two innocent children while driving under the influence. We'll discuss the trial, her recent conviction, and reflect on the dire need for responsible behavior to prevent such irreversible tragedies.

Next, we journey through the tragic story of Deja Maldondo, who found herself entangled in a nightmare after the death of her husband, Eli Dominguez. Brandon Toseland, a supposed friend, offered solace but soon turned manipulative and abusive, isolating Deja and controlling every aspect of her life. This episode sheds light on the red flags of toxic relationships and the immense difficulties victims face when seeking help. We'll also share personal anecdotes about interactions with law enforcement and the crucial role of a supportive network. The episode culminates with the gut-wrenching revelation of the abuser's role in the death of Deja's child, a stark reminder of the urgent need to recognize and act upon signs of abuse.

https://www.ktnv.com/news/crime/attorney-shares-timeline-leading-up-to-murder-of-a-4-year-old-boy

https://www.reviewjournal.com/crime/courts/mother-of-slain-child-tells-grand-jury-she-was-held-captive-for-months-2560184/

https://www.ktnv.com/news/crime/las-vegas-man-accused-of-murdering-4-year-old-claims-mother-colluded-in-hiding-the-body

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music

Send us a text

Can wrongful convictions shatter more than just a person's freedom? This episode of "What We Lose in the Shadows" peels back the layers of a tragic miscarriage of justice that forever altered the life of Anthony Broadwater.

We dive deep into the case of Alice Seaborn, a Syracuse University freshman who bravely reported her rape in May 1981. Despite her attacker being convicted, the truth took a devastating turn. Learn how a producer's relentless quest for justice and a private investigator's crucial role ultimately exonerated Broadwater after 16 long years. We explore the profound impact of such wrongful convictions on individuals' lives, highlighting Broadwater's struggles to reintegrate into society and his heartbreaking decision not to have children. This episode sheds light on the systemic flaws and biases that lead to such injustices, resonating with similar cases like the Central Park Five. Join us for a compelling reminder of why thorough and fair investigations are essential for true justice.

How an innocent Black man served time for the rape of author Alice Sebold | Race | The Guardian
NY to Pay Broadwater $5.5 Million After Wrongful Conviction for Sebold’s Rape - The New York Times (nytimes.com)

Contact us at: whatweloseintheshadows@gmail.com



Background music by Michael Shuller Music