What happens when obsession becomes a refuge, when a high score becomes a legacy, and when a rivalry turns into a morality play? This week on Make Me A Nerd, Mandy Kaplan goes deep into the pixelated world of Donkey Kong, a place where the stakes are high, the egos are massive, and the quarters just keep coming. Mandy is joined by Megan Isser, a former documentary filmmaker turned professor of film, who brings her nuanced lens to the unlikely drama chronicled in the cult-classic documentary The King of Kong.

This isn’t just a story about a video game—it’s a story about identity, community, and the fraught pursuit of greatness.

Billy Mitchell, the reigning champion with a penchant for arrogance and hot sauce, becomes the perfect foil for Steve Wiebe, the underdog science teacher whose life has been a series of almosts—almost a great athlete, almost a great musician, almost a winner. The film, directed by Seth Gordon, captures their rivalry with the precision of a Donkey Kong hammer smashing barrels, raising larger questions about what it means to devote yourself to something utterly niche, but deeply important.

Megan and Mandy dissect the film’s narrative structure, its unforgettable cast of characters (from Walter Day’s referee stripes to Brian Kuh’s kill-screen evangelism), and the fine line between celebrating nerd culture and mocking it. They also explore the documentary’s impact on the genre itself, as well as the ethical choices filmmakers face when portraying their subjects.

Is Billy Mitchell the villain we want him to be? Is Steve Wiebe the hero we need him to be? And what does it all say about the lengths we’ll go to for recognition, even in an arcade?

This episode is a love letter to obsession and the people who find meaning in the unlikeliest places. But it’s also a meditation on humanity, on what drives us to compete, to connect, and to care.

Press play. Because somewhere in the background, a Donkey Kong cabinet is still buzzing, and a potential kill screen is always looming.

Links & Notes

• Mandy Kaplan on Instagram (@mandy_kaplan_clavens)
• Make Me A Nerd – Official Website
• The King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters (IMDb)
• Twin Galaxies – Official Website

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

This week, Mandy slays into Buffy the Vampire Slayer, a show she'd previously avoided. Joined by Pete Wright and Kyle Olson, she confronts her assumptions about vampires and the supernatural in stake and song.

Before the nostalgia kicks in, Kyle addresses the complicated legacy of Joss Whedon, emphasizing the importance of separating the art from the artist. This is a conversation about reclaiming the Buffy fandom as a source of joy, setting the stage for a more nuanced discussion.

Are Pete and Kyle, middle-aged straight white men, the right vessels for Buffy fandom? Yes, yes, a thousand times yes. In fact, it's their experience that shines a spotlight on just how broad the fandom of this show reaches.

This is an exploration of that fandom, the power of nostalgia, and the complex relationship between art and its creators. Along the way, they patrol through S2E3: School Hard, S4E10: Hush, and S6E7: Once More With Feeling.

Links & Notes

• Evan Ross Katz's book, Into Every Generation a Slayer is Born
• Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Hulu/Disney+)
• Buffy the Vampire Slayer (JustWatch)

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Dive deep into the swirling vortex of nerddom with Mandy and Dana as they dissect the wildly popular A Court of Thorns and Roses. Mandy grapples with the thorny intricacies of faerie lore, romanticy, and the age-old question: just how does one maintain hygiene in a pre-modern, magically infused realm?

Dana, the seasoned reader and fantasy aficionado, acts as Mandy's Virgil, guiding her through the labyrinthine world of Sarah J. Maas's prose. They explore the surprising parallels to Beauty and the Beast, the allure of world-building (even when it leaves you scratching your head), and the irresistible pull of a good, old-fashioned, fairy-fueled romance.

This episode is a must-listen for anyone who's ever wondered about the finer points of faerie etiquette, the power of BookTok, or the enduring appeal of a story that blends romance, fantasy, and just a touch of good old-fashioned gore. You might even learn a thing or two about Taylor Swift along the way. Trust us, it's more connected than you think.

Links & Notes

• A Court of Thorns and Roses
• Sarah J. Maas
• Throne of Glass
• Fourth Wing
• BookTok

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

What happens when fear isn’t just in the shadows, but in the walls of your own home? When the weight of loss becomes a creature you can see, hear, and—perhaps worst of all—cannot escape?

This week, Mandy invites filmmaker, podcaster, and friend Tommy Metz III back to unpack one of the most unsettling films of the last decade: The Babadook.

Mandy and Tommy explore the architecture of horror itself, evaluating how Jennifer Kent’s 2014 cult classic reshaped the genre. From the film’s muted color palette to its sound design, they unpack how the movie doesn’t just tell a bedtime story—it feels like one.

What if the Babadook isn’t just a monster, but an author, a symbol of a mother’s unresolved trauma? Tommy presents a theory that might just make you rethink every frame of the film, complete with exhibits and photographic evidence. Mandy recounts her own nightmares, her love-hate relationship with creepy children’s books, and her newfound obsession with the film’s unsettling layers.

And what about this for unexpected twists: How did a shadowy, top-hat-wearing figure become a queer icon? Yes, you read that right. The Babadook’s journey from psychological horror to internet meme is a subplot worthy of its own deep dive.

Links & Notes

• Find Tommy on All The Feelings
• The Babadook on streaming platforms
• Photos referenced during the episode

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Mandy Kaplan embarks on a cosmic quest to decode the enigmatic realms of sci-fi aboard the USS Orville, captained by the comedic stylings of Seth MacFarlane, with Matthew Fox, host of Star Wars Generations and Superhero Ethics.

This isn't a show that's obsessed with warp speeds or phaser frequencies. Instead, Matthew sees science fiction as a mirror reflecting the complexities of our own world, a lens through which to examine ethics, humanity, and the very fabric of consciousness.

Mandy sets off with The Orville, a show she initially dismissed as "frat-boy humor," and discovers the surprising depth beneath the surface. Together, they explore pivotal episodes: "About a Girl," a poignant exploration of gender identity and cultural relativism, and "Mad Idolatry," a sharp critique of religious fervor and its potential for manipulation. The Orville is a space adventure and a philosophical thought experiment wrapped in witty banter and surprising emotional resonance.

Links & Notes

• The Ethical Panda
• Star Wars Generations
• Superhero Ethics

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Mandy embarks on a quixotic quest to decode the enigmatic world of One Piece. Yes, that One Piece – the sprawling, seemingly endless saga of pirates, devil fruits, and a rubber-limbed protagonist named Monkey D. Luffy. Now, before you dismiss this as mere children’s fare, consider this: One Piece, like a meticulously crafted Trojan Horse, smuggles profound themes of friendship, loyalty, and the enduring power of dreams within its vibrant, often absurd exterior.

Zach Logan, the erudite host of the One Piece Podcast, serves as Mandy’s Virgil, guiding her through this labyrinthine narrative. He, a veteran of the double secret life – the one where international espionage is but a mundane Tuesday – reveals the surprising depth and emotional resonance lurking beneath the surface of this thousand-plus episode epic. They discuss the nuances of the original anime, the kinetic energy of the recent “Fan Letter” special, and the surprisingly effective live-action adaptation, a production Zach’s own mother, along with a legion of other moms, inexplicably adores.

But the true heart of this episode lies in the unexpected parallels they draw between One Piece and other seemingly disparate narratives, from Homer’s Odyssey to the nerdy depths of the television show Lost. They explore the enduring appeal of the “ragtag crew on a mission” trope, the way it taps into our primal yearning for connection and belonging. In doing so, they reveal the universality of One Piece, its ability to transcend cultural boundaries and speak to something deep within the human spirit. So, grab your straw hat, hoist the Jolly Roger, and prepare to be swept away by the world of One Piece.

Links & Notes

• One Piece Podcast
• Zach on Bluesky
• One Piece Podcast on Bluesky
• One Piece Podcast Patreon

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

This week on Make Me A Nerd, Mandy goes deep into the bewitching woods of "Agatha All Along," a spin-off of the already perplexing "WandaVision." To help her grapple with the show's unique narrative structure, its blend of sitcom tropes and supernatural intrigue, and its connection to the broader tapestry of the MCU she’s got her new best Marvel friend, Matt Cole from the Debate This! Podcast!

They dissect the lingering effects of Wanda's hex spell on Agatha Harkness, exploring how it traps her in a cycle of sitcom archetypes, blurring the lines between reality and illusion. They examine the significance of Aubrey Plaza's arrival, questioning her motivations and her connection to Agatha's past. They probe the show's subtle nods to the history of witchcraft, tracing the threads of real-world folklore woven into the fictional narrative.

But the conversation extends beyond the specifics of the plot. They unpack the challenges of adapting complex comic book lore for the screen, the delicate balance between fan service and accessibility, and the tendency of superhero narratives to recycle familiar tropes. They question the effectiveness of exposition-heavy recaps and primers, arguing that sometimes, a surface-level engagement can be more rewarding than a deep dive into obscure trivia.

Ultimately, this episode is about the inherent human desire to make sense of complex narratives, to find connection in shared experiences, and to laugh at the absurdity of it all. It’s an exploration of the joys and frustrations of fandom, the tension between casual viewing and obsessive analysis, and the realization that even in the most fantastical worlds, the human element remains at the core. So, join coven as they unravel the mysteries of Agatha, navigating the convoluted corridors of the MCU with a mix of curiosity, skepticism, and a healthy appreciation for the weird.

Links & Notes

• Debate This!
• Avenge This!
• Bahnfyre PR

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

In this delightfully nerdy episode, Mandy joins the ranks of the Marvel Cinematic Universe for the (sort of) first time with podcaster and comic book aficionado Justin Jaeger. Like a modern-day anthropologist venturing into uncharted territory, Mandy explores the mystifying world of Loki, Marvel's mercurial trickster god, through the lens of a complete newcomer.

Justin, whose personal comic collection once aspired to the likes of the Library of Alexandria with 8,000 volumes, guides Mandy through the intricacies of Marvel lore while accidentally turning their discussion into an impromptu therapy session. The pair pull apart the charming paradox of Tom Hiddleston's Loki—a villain so charismatic that Mandy initially mistakes him for the hero.

From comparing the show to Silence of the Lambs to debating the state of Marvel's special effects budget, this episode offers a refreshingly uninitiated perspective on superhero culture. Whether you're a seasoned comic collector or someone who only knows Tom Hiddleston as "Taylor Swift's ex who dances on Graham Norton," this conversation bridges the gap between mainstream and nerd culture with wit and warmth.

Links & Notes

• Jayge’s Pages (Justin's YouTube book review channel)
• Loki on Disney+
• WandaVision on Disney+
• The MCU Timeline Guide for Beginners
• Tom Hiddleston's Thor Audition Tape

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.