A rich and fun experience incredibly well read.

At once deWitt's voice echoes the works of Dahl in its rich and varied portrayal of one boy's journey to find and keep a hold of love. A cast of characters emerge from an idyllic landscape full of bloodlust and sex. Just like are Sisters Brothers, the experience is unique, the story bold and understated. Great to listen to on walks.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Strange tale..

Would you try another book written by Patrick deWitt or narrated by Simon Prebble?

No it was a bit too strange and not very wonderful. I guess S.P. done his best.

Did Undermajordomo Minor inspire you to do anything?

no ..I just stuck with it to the end . its now gone !

Any additional comments?

it was a silly tail with not much to it ,didn't like the ending . never mind someone out there will enjoy it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Disappointing after The Sisters Brothers

Simon Prebble is an excellent narrator but essentially this novel lacks any surprise, revelation or real character development. After the invention of The Sisters Brothers, which is great, one has the feeling that the inventive spark left the author and that he almost wilfully ignored chances to do something unusual or original. I persevered to the end hoping something would rescue the story, but I have to say it's a dull book and very disappointing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I am still thinking about it

After Ablutions and Sisters Brothers I was excited, then became progressively more disappointed as I read, then expectant again believing I was being set up for some marvellously contrasting event, then curious, then questioning again. Eventually I found myself wishing I could call Patrick and ask; Why did you do this? Is it an early story that you feel you can now publish? Or were you trying to avoid sensationalism and uniqueness in your writing as a discipline, a personal challenge to write of the ordinary more beautifully than of the beautiful? Were you looking down on your happy place? A world you withdraw to?

The thing is though that I am still thinking about this story and this place. I think we all have our own imaginary places and they often have Easts and Wests and mountains and snow and train carriages with compartments, where we can live simple lives without our everyday distractions while we keep the machine turning and where we are not frustrated by our place in the world.

I once wrote of my own land one day while bored at work, which was similar geographically with mountains and snow, and with a kind encouraging and benevolent ruler who believed in self development for all. Unfortunately I was unable to achieve this as my boss didn't share these views, being from the mean crappy kingdom next door.

My review title does not mean I am trying to decide the title, it means I am still, and will be for some time, thinking about this story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

loved it

Characters, Reader , great stuff. listened twice. Enjoyed it immensely. Love the liar in the main charater

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A very enjoyable tale

Great, funny, creepy, very well narrated. And worth it for the dinner party scene alone :)

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

A strange but involving tale.

it took me a while to get into the book at first as I couldn't connect with the central character Lucy, perhaps because he himself was so adrift and disconnected. Gradually , the story sucked me in. The formality of the language at first irritated me but it suits the timeless , slightly magical feel of the story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Couldn't get on with it at all

Tried a few times with this but i couldn't get in to at all. I hated the characters and didn't find it funny at all.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!