loved it

Must listen for any Libertines fans. I loved this book as it really gives you an insight into what was happening in the lives of Carl, Pete, John and Gary.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A Book of Albion

Always being more on the Doherty side of the Libertines partnership, I took the recent publication of Doherty’s autobiography A Likely Lad as the trigger to also pick up Carl Barat’s own earlier book Threepenny Memoir: The Lives of a Libertine (2010) to compare and contrast. The same tale told from two different angles and in widely different styles. Kind of like an English A-level homework assignment but with more comical mishaps involving drugs and hospitals.

Barat instantly wins points for reading his himself. Always a welcome feature, however I was slightly concerned going into it that his plummy voice might get grating. It doesn’t, and adds that necessary personal touch as he reveals many personal insights. Although shorter than Doherty’s, it is far the better written of the two with some quite descriptive and, yes, at times moving images painted. The excitement of being in London. Being part of that machine the city has become. The history to stand within.

I must confess, I have had run ins with both characters over the years. Living in the same postcode for much of the late-nineties and early noughties and sharing gig bills with one or the other or both, but I don’t ‘know them’ know them. It was lovely to hear of places and indeed people that I do know, some of whom are now long gone, and were brought to life again. The excitement of that era in London, the pitfalls of securing gigs and record labels. The pitfalls of the people. Lovers. Dealers. The mischief and comradery that only a band experiences, no matter how small.

Doherty’s book is far longer and is read by actor Ben Elliot. I think he does a great job and quickly morphs into Doherty. It is believable you are listening to Doherty telling you his story. The ghost writing by Simon Spence, however careful, is occasionally obvious and slightly tabloid, but it suits the stories within. It is also nice to hear Doherty, so often pained as a callous chancer, being humble and warm about those around him. His book is, at times, hilarious too, which probably captures the vibe of his music far better than any fawning reviews focusing on his troubles and artistry. Being in a band, especially in the post-Strokes noughties London, is absurd and surreal and if you can’t look at yourself or act with tongue firmly in cheek, you don’t deserve the straw hat, rosary beads and leather jacket uniform you represent.

Another confession, I’ve never been too sold on anything beyond the first Libertines album. Sure, I know most of the other stuff, solo and otherwise, but they’re not my go-to London bangers. Nonetheless, hearing how some of these later tracks were written and recorded is fascinating and in some cases made me go and listen back to them again for the first time in a decade. And after all, that’s what you need from this type of book. Rockumentary, if you will.

It’s about 20 years since most of the events within these books happened but hearing about them at the time, albeit from afar, only feels like it was sometime a few weeks ago. Those halcyon nights running wild as kids. Pub. Gig. Disco. New lover. Repeat. Now we’re all older and enjoy sitting at home with an audiobook, these are the perfect pair to bring it all back. Both get a four but for different reasons. Barat for being better written and self-narrated, but Doherty for being more expansive and funny. The truth is, both compliment each other, like the men in question, and both should be bought together. That would be a five.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

LOVED IT

great to hear carl talking, and his tales of the libertines are legendary, long live the libertines and let the albion sail on for years to come!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Honest and genuine if a little short

Enjoyed this memoir although at just 4 hours it left me wanting to hear more. Shorter and slightly less eloquent than Peter’ s A Likely Lad, it is however written and narrated in a genuine style by the author. I noted some reviewers comments about Carl’s delivery and while I can see the perception of disinterest in narrating, I reached the conclusion that this is his natural way of speaking and managed to get into the flow of it. Some honest descriptions of drug and alcohol use and all the usual rock and roll antics but written in a self reflective way that helps you understand how this lifestyle comes about. You can see that some of the journey is painful to talk about and also that Carl’s insecurities are real making him all the more human. Written a while ago, I’d love to hear about the next chapter as Carl journeys into fatherhood, stable relationships and of course the return of The Libertines! Enjoyed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Hard work

Carl's almost disinterested narration, made a subject I would be very interested in, pretty boring.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Excellent

Absolutely fascinating from start to finish. Carl has a beautiful grasp of the English language. Expertly written with interesting content, what’s not to like. 5*

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A work of art

Insightful audio book. Delving into a side of Carl we don't see. He spoke so fast at times so I was occasionally rewind the audio.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Insightful

Beautiful, witty, heartbreaking at times - I was a big fan of Carl's in my youth and this re-stoked my passion for his music as well as filling me with nostalgia. Really recommend this.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Great listen

An enlightening and honest memior, really enjoyed it. I can relate. definitely worth a listen.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Honesty of a rock star! A fantastic & chaotic life

I love Carls use of language, beautifully written & read. Carl is a musician I've always admired. The raw honesty in his book is resfreshing - just plug in straight, turn it up to eleven & enjoy the ride. A*

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!