Simple but fun

Short and simple, but a lot of fun. There was a point near the end where it was difficult to understand what just happened. The following parts, are way too expensive for 1 hour productions though.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A really well thought out adaptaion

The voice acting and Foley were excellent and really brought the story to life. In many ways, this is a shining example of audio storytelling.
I'd listen to the others, but I am a little reluctant to pay full price/credit for an hour of audio, no matter how good the story and voice work are. Though I also understand how much work has been put into the production. Somewhat torn.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Disappointing

No narration just character acting which is very good, however the plot is weak and writing also not a patch on the original Steve Jackson & Ian Livingstone books
I read as a teenager which was my reason for downloading, a decision I regret wasting credit on!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

SPOILER WARNING: Avoid to save you a disappointment

While I was more than happy to discover that the old fighting fantasy game books are being adapted into canonised audiobooks, after listening to this, the first story in the series which adapts the first book I ever brought from the series, I felt let down by the cheesy, stale and dull way the story played out.
Naturally when adapting any form of role-playing game, you have to cut out a lot of pre-existing content to make an entertainment package succinct enough for consumer’s palates. This I had no issue with, as the original story did proceed with a series of random monster encounters of various sizes and threat while finding the keys to Zagor’s treasure chest.
The canonised protagonist, Vale Moonwing, was neither compelling or bad, and older for a YA game book protagonist than I expected, which would have been a welcome twist to the tired old trope of the young adventurer filled with a sense of destiny. Yet she is a but a very one dimensional elf woman armed with a very basic motive and quest to kill Zagor, the warlock of firetop mountain.
To ensure that the protagonist does not spend the time narrating to herself her actions and reactions to the obstacles she will encounter, she is accompanied by a rugged welsh-sounding adventurer and treasure hunter named Cassius Stormblade, whose purpose is to be Vale’s foil, a companion with an additional, more selfish motivation to enter firetop mountain, while additionally seeking a dwarf friend of his being held prisoner by Zagor.
Zagor is your standard one dimensional moustache twirling devilishly British warlock who is evil just because and so naturally seeks to stop Vale from slaying him. He is aided by his whip slinging Orc Chieftain and underling played by what appears to be a black British man, not exactly an ideal casting choice considering the originally problematic conceptions of orcs as racialised evil ‘Other’ humans through the white Eurocentric lenses employed by Tolkien and his anti-saracen swarthy depictions of orcs, Robert E.Howard with black races in Conan and the earlier Christian colonial demonisation of First Nation and native tribesmen that influenced the orcs in dungeons and dragons. A performance is a performance but we deserve better than having black and people of colour continuing to be cast in monstrous roles in the white dominated realm of high fantasy.
The story plays out at a surprisingly fast speed. I started it while running and finished it while sat in the garden within an hour. It wasn’t exactly an enthralling, immersive story compared to the Titans on this platform like Neil Gaiman’s various adapted works on this platform, and I made myself stay with the audio book just to see it finish and if it had the narrative hook for me to want to purchase the next story. It did not.
This was a very run of the mill, cliched, unoriginal, non-atmospheric and quite frankly a boring fantasy romp. While it pays tribute to the famous moments in the books that players of the game loved, it left a lot to be desired as a fantasy story. The music is cheesy and 80’s and droll, and the acting was standard, with the writing and the emotional pulls failing to convince me to continue listening to the series.
As gutted as I was to be writing such a negative review and slandering an adaption of the game book series that fed my imagination as a kid, there are much better works out there to spend my runs and breaks listening to. This needs to be adapted much better and with more investment than a sub-par fantasy audiobook.
If you’re a nostalgist and wish to reminisce on your first fighting fantasy game book which happened to be firetop mountain, by all means indulge a credit for an evening listen. If you are cursed with high expectations like myself, avoid this by a mile and look into works done by BBC Radio 4 and Audible Originals.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful