Downgraded?

The French politician mentioned in the section 'The Judgment of Paris', is Théophile Delcassé, 1852-1923. And not Déclassé as the narrator would have it throughout. (Déclassé is French for downgraded.)

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Fascinating complexities of pre-war European politics

Lots of interesting information but can be difficult to follow at times. Best to make notes as you go to all the players and their roles.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Desperately, desperately poor narration...

Such a shame- a book that sold so well and that I was really looking forward to listening to is ruined by a narrator who appears to have the reading age of a primary school child. The problem begins right at the start: 'causal' in the book becomes "casual" in the narration and the word "Balkan" can only be recognised in context, not because of the way it's said. And on and on.

Really ruins the listening experience and as this is my first try with audible it's not an auspicious start.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

First rate

It shows deep knowledge and many fine judgements, and he has an eye for human detail too.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Groundbreaking and riveting. Narration good enough

Narration is totally fine, I could follow along no problem. The book itself is magnificent.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Drifting into Hell

I turned to this book, after having it in my ‘to be read’ shelf for a while. I saw an article about the author Christopher Clark, who had stated ‘not to compare his book to the recent war in Ukraine’. As I read further modern politicians have poured over the work with ex-German Chancellor Angela Merkel recommending it at every possible turn. With this, I knew there would be something special here.

Ultimately it is an excellent and complete book on the causes of the First World War. I was really impressed and simply could not put it down. The concept is explained in the title, that the European powers before 1914 slowly slipped into a conflict that a majority did not want. It blows away the aged argument that Germany was entirely to blame, that the Kaiser and political elites were warmongers and criminals.

Instead it places the complex diplomatic and cultural relations between states at the forefront, with unfortunate event followed by disastrous (but not fatal in isolation) decision again and again. Central to it all is the new, ambitious, Slavic and regicidal Kingdom of Serbia. A same Balkan country with a big match. Clark’s analysis covers all angles, international relations, state’s aims and objectives, did they try and prevent war? Why they feared it? What a ‘preventative war’ means, who actually made decisions, what decisions and actions were taken and how press and public mood influenced these decisions. Interestingly how monarchs, statesmen and the public reacted in the fateful days and ultimate declarations of war.

The content of Clark’s work is always captivating and his level of knowledge is astounding. I have said in my other reviews of his works that there is a mixture of genius with frustration as I feel he is not the best writer. Sleepwalkers is without doubt his best work and is written in his best pros. Although undue crowded sentences creep in from time to time it is nowhere near the level experienced in Iron Kingdom or Kaiser Wilhelm II.

I could go through this entire book again and learn new points, arguments and facts. With a topic I have read as a student, it is an asset to one’s library. For me I have long agreed with the findings, that no one person or state can soles be to blame, each made mistakes and must bear the burden in their individual ways. None foresaw the catastrophe which befell them and Europe’s greatest tragedy which came out of it as the worlds tore itself apart.

End note: I agree with the other reviews that the narration is not great and difficult in places. However it was not bad enough to put me off listening.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

very detailed. you need to stay on the story.

a lot of names and details make it a full report. but you need to read through it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The conclusion which has profound implications for today’s world and the study of history.

An excellent book. The author writes well and some of the pen portraits are fascinating and even funny. The conclusion poses some interesting questions about the stories that statesmen and nations tell themselves and the processes of history. These have important insights for today’s international scene.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Most interesting

A clear and concise description of the diplomacy that failed to prevent war in 1914

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Awful narration

Great book (apparently) spoiled by un-listenable narration with very basic pronunciation errors. Narration is not as bad at the beginning so I got a few hours in before giving up.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful