Great little stories

Plum at his early best.
Some lovely crafted dialogue and laugh out loud moments.
Well told.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Reader is the issue

This reader has by far the most unpleasantly superciliously sly-sounding & condescending tones, from his voice alone exactly the sort who I'd never feel able to trust with a set of house keys were he to be found to be a next door neighbour... and indeed were he to be so and unlikely to move away, he'd be one of the reasons I'd find would contribute to my moving household elsewhere myself. Indeed before I've penetrated very much past the earlier stages, I find I can bear his slimy tones no longer. I'm an experienced audio books consumer and have, I assure you, never so reacted to any other book reader. Quite why this voice was considered suitable for this function, is beyond me. If I'd been the auditioning listener at his audition's trial I'd have told him to amend his style completely - or collect his cards on his way out.
All of which means there are quite a few Wodehouse works now beyond reach to me since this man, Frederick Davidson, appears in the reader credit. Which might explain why these are in the freebie section of Audible's extended listening list. In this case, being free is not enough reason to suffer this "performance" in my remaining hours & days.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A useful anthology for short listens

A collection of Wodehouse short stories that serves very well as an audiobook to hold in reserve and dip into when you want a quick 20 minute listen.



If you want to listen for several hours at a time, then a longer single story would be a better bet as these can become a bit "samey" if listened to end-to-end.



Personally, I was not wildly taken with the narration, but not to the extent of marring the pleasure of Wodehouse's writing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Change the narrator!

Narrator puts you off straight away, not sure why he was chosen but is impossible to listen to

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Posh and poorly read

No inflexion change of tone or pace. Made listening to PG a painful experience . Sorry but a dud.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

A poor read

A great labour finishing this poorly put together and badly narrated mosh mash bad stuff

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

You will NOT enjoy this version

If this book wasn’t for you, who do you think might enjoy it more?

I never found out! The narration is so naïve and poor that within a chapter I was so annoyed with Mr Davidson for ruining the brilliant PG Wodehouse that I abandoned the story

What was most disappointing about P. G. Wodehouse’s story?

Nothing, just the sub standard narration!

What didn’t you like about Frederick Davidson’s performance?

Everything!! You've caused your own problems by previously using the incomparable services of Jonathan Cecil who not only reads the words, he acts the parts. His diction is perfect, he has a thousand voices, he reads at the correct speed and emphasises at the correct moment. I'm afraid Mr Davidson is very poor in comparison and I won't buy him again.

If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from The Man Upstairs and Other Stories?

I couldn't comment as I never got past the first chapter of this poor performance.

Any additional comments?

Jonathan Cecil is brilliant! Paul Shelley, Graham Seed, Nigel Lambert, Dinsdale Landen, Jeremy Sinden and James Saxon are acceptable and Ian Carmichael disappointing. David Ian Davies and Frederick Davidson however are awful, almost childish in the way they read and become immensely annoying. 'Jill the Reckless' is just as bad as the 'Man Upstairs' above and I shall not be investing in other titles read by these really poor narrators! I'm only sorry that I had to discover this the hard way and that my collection of Wodehouse will never include these titles!!!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Appalling narration

The narrator speaks through his nose - it is insufferable. Completely ruined the audiobook. How on earth did anyone reach the conclusion that this was of merchantable quality?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

unbearable narrator

The narrator has ruined the experience for me. I couldn't even finish the first story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful