Moving but painful exploration of alienatiin

There are many interesting aspects to this roman a clef, and long excruciating passages of a young person's experience of being out of place among others and within themselves. The author's sometimes monotone reading voice adds to the overall effect. But the narrative pulls you in and flashes of humour provide moments of contrast. Overall though I cannot escape a feeling of 'stasis', of being trapped on an alien planet with no clear sense of the possibility of escape. But maybe this is 21st century realism?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Might have been better with a different narrator

I found it relaxing to follow the main character around her life, elements were funny & relatable - I especially liked the bits about language and east European cultures as it’s not something that comes up a lot in books. Unfortunately I found the narrator very difficult - she read it in such a deadpan way and it was difficult to connect to. Might have been better with a more animated narrator or just in physical format.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A rather juvenile romp

As the title suggests, Elif Batuman's novel explores linguistics and Russian literature through the eyes of a young Harvard undergraduate, Selin. The character falls in love with an older, neurotic Hungarian mathematics student, and travels to his country to be near him. It is occasionally humorous, and describes a rite of passage - but no more than that. Unfortunately, at times it is rather banal and tedious.

While Batuman's writing is to be desired, the content fell short as the narrative varies between sharp and rambling. The naivety of Selin also appears slightly unbelievable, and would probably be better geared at a younger audience.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Falls flat

The narration is a bit dry making it hard to know if things are meant to be funny or not. I downloaded it as it was the "editors pick" and it turned out to be a struggle to finish.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Relatable

The best book I've read for a while, fantastically narrated and laugh out loud funny. But this is not just a comedy - it's a deep and thought provoking novel about real life.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

“Outstays its welcome” - how true

Having chosen this book after listening to Graham Norton’s book club, I listened again to that episode. The reviewers were spot on, and Graham’s summary that the book “outstays its welcome” perfectly describes my own view.
Despite some lovely writing, and so much insight into the naivety of adolescence that I could really relate to, it just goes on far too long without anything of interest to hear and I was honestly glad when it finished. I wonder too if the writer herself as narrator was a good choice - I found her voice became increasingly irritating. The end was so abrupt I wonder if she’d had enough herself. Or perhaps this book is better read than heard.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Meandering towards nothing

I couldn’t wait for it to end. Nothing happens. Characters are insufferable and unlikeable. The protagonist is childlike and painfully naive. It reads as of a year in the life of a rich and sheltered dullard with no storyline whatsoever. Absolute snooze-fest that just went on and on and on and on and on and on…….. This is why I don’t read as much as I’d like as I’m nervous I’ll use one of my credits on something like this so I’m hesitant to buy them.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Started well but became very monotonous

I really enjoyed the first part of this novel. The chapters about student life at Harvard and the eccentric personalities were very engaging. The story took an interesting turn, but the main character and her love interest were so limited and both seemed self-indulgent and lacking in depth (though clearly we were supposed to think they were too deep for their own good). I’m afraid the flat delivery didn’t help either. Overall I thought it was disappointing. Sorry - I really did want to like it and I forced myself to finish it in order to give it a fair chance. But it didn’t really recover.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!