Don't read this if you are eating!

Well the story was OK, the characters were a bit thin and lacklustre - but what really got my goat was the comment that she 'had to drag herself out of bed because of her sodden sanitory towel, also when various people hawked thick mucous up and spat.

These references add absolutely nothing to the story and frankly are revolting - I was actually eating when I listened to the bit about the ST. For goodness sake, it's totally unnecessary and thoroughly revolting!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Okay. But the Finnish pronunciation was awful.

The book was okay. I listened to it until the end, which I won't do if a book fails to engage me. As a person whose first language was Finnish the names were butchered. I cannot blame the narrator but surely someone Finnish could have been found to get the names said in a way which didn't hurt my ears. The Hell's Angels sub story line didn't really work or go anywhere. I suspect the jarring Finnish really stopped me getting into the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Pretty good( especially for Finnophiles).

I ought to declare an enthusiasm for things Finnish as I certainly wouldn't have chosen this book were it not for the setting. It is an enjoyable listen and some of the characters rise above the two-dimensions typical of police procedurals. The old cop Esko, a racist grump who doesn't quite know where his life has gone wrong, was my favourite - he makes you cringe but you can't help feeling sorry for him. I was so worried when he started to feel he was being followed by homicidal gang members so I guess the book engaged me emotionally. The reflections about Finland, its climate and culture were also interesting. As for the plot - it's intriguing enough to keep you listening altho' this is never a big issue for me; does anyone really care who did it? Would certainly listen to another book by this writer.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Scintillating delivery of an outstanding story!

Would you consider the audio edition of The Defenceless to be better than the print version?

Before listening to The Defenceless I had previously read the book and enjoyed it immensely. Undoubtedly it was one of my favourite reads of 2015 and as well as being a hugely timely and relevant novel it was also a remarkably profound insight into the life of migrants. To my mind, Kati Hiekkapelto is the finest exponent of urban noir and this gritty storyline packs a very weighty punch. Low on violence, blood and gore but this is powerful stuff!

I had not previously heard the narrator and her impassioned delivery certainly added something to the novel. An audiobook really comes to life when the narrator sounds as involved in the story as the listener and this was the case. A wonderful sense of urgency in the voice of Julie Masiey at moments of heightened tension also played well. I also appreciated the subtle distinction between characters voices which made this all the more riveting. I hope that this narrator provides the audio for future novels as she did a cracking job.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Undoubtedly Anna Fekete. A brilliantly realistic portrayal of a modern woman facing life as a migrant in a new country. Believable and human, unlike so many fictional cops!

Which scene did you most enjoy?

The banter between Anna and her bigoted colleague Esko. Initially coming across as a racist, drunken investigator with no sympathy for migrants and the situations that bring them to another country, his interaction witn Anna forces him to reconsider his opinions.

Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

I spent a long time thinking about The Defenceless - it made me think about the sadness of just how easy so many people in society seem to find it to tar every immigrant with the same brush. A different situation brings each and every settler to a new country and without considering individual situations we cannot emphasise with people.

Any additional comments?

A splendid narration of a book which will resonate. Anna Fekete is brilliantly brought to life. Timely and relevant.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Finnish Procedural

As a Finnish police procedural, this is a little intriguing. The story is well plotted; intricate without losing its focus. The heroine is a little feeble but then she’s not much more than a rookie.
I recommend it though you will have to put up with the occasionally irritating narrative where inflexions and voice moderation often jar. Would have been improved had the narrator read the story in advance and worked out where the stresses were needed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!