Disappointed

I gave this a good go but am not enjoying it. I recently read (as in, an actual book) The Black Cloud and thought it was excellent. But I’m not enjoying this audiobook.

In the first place I find it a bit pulpy and sexist - to be expected in some ways perhaps but it still jars. The female characters are all ciphers, even when they’ve got a significant role in the story. Maybe it’s down to the narrator, I can’t tell. The narrator is fine when she is delivering straightforward narration but I think she gets lost with so many different character voices. All the men have the same strange intonation and the women seem to go up an octave, despite the fact that the narrator’s voice is already quite high. Anyway, I can’t tell who is meant to be speaking half the time.

My quandary now is whether I return the book, since I recently had a stern email from audible accusing me of ‘abusing’ their service by returning too many books. My kneejerk reaction was to cancel my membership, as audible need to remember that customers are privileging them with our custom, not the other way around. Still, I was tempted back with a half price offer. But an unlistenable book remains unlistenable even when it was half price. So I don’t think I’ll be staying with audible too much longer to pay for the privilege of books I won’t listen to. Shame really 😕

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Very much a product of its time.

The story is thematically great, but I found it difficult to absorb as the voice actor is very high-pitched and yet flat, regardless of the character being performed, and the narrative is close to a science fiction “Mills and Boon”. The only sentence missing was along the lines of- “I wanted to object, but Roger was so rugged and handsome, and I was only a girl, so I kept quiet”. As per the title, very much a book of its time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A very English perspective to science fantasy

I was enthralled in the story ,it kept you listening for more. A very idealistic story with a beurocratic view of England. The failings of the characters kept you thinking who will succeed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!