Great book

Great book but the reader has a very annoying "ibit" tick that distracts from the story in a shallow way. Information wise, excellent read

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great narrator but audio presentation needed more thought.

The narrator is great, but this book is very quote heavy. More or less the first 2/3 of the book deals with how various media outlets portray socialist states & much of this is directly quoted text. As a listener, this makes it very, very difficult to keep track of what is a quote & what is the author’s own own writing. This should have used a bare minimum of two different narrators, but probably three, so that direct quotes could have their own narrator voice. The narrator was also told to read aloud the various reference markers that are useless to a listener as there are no references to reference.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Excellent book - poor narration

Kristian goes through his thesis very well showing that all socialist regimes were considered socialist at some point (most recently Venezuela but traditionally USSR, China, Cuba etc) and that every regime goes through three stages from extreme adulation by the chattering classes to the veneer coming off / doubts about the system, and finally to "that wasn't real socialism".

He also brought up many examples of Saint Jeremy and his comrades praising many of these regimes and making disparaging comments about victims of the regime (for example, Corbyn refers to Cuban emigres in the US escaping Communism as "the gangsters of Miami") which is important to help us remember how close we were to having that dangerous man in power and how we should do all we can to prevent that in the future.

The only issue I have with the audiobook is the narration - the narrator's style just doesn't fit the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Interesting if repetitive to prove the point

First and last or second last chapters are where the really interesting discussion takes place, the other chapters are the case studies to prove the point.

Tracks left wing observers reactions to Socialist experiments and proposes a pattern of celebrating a new utopia in the making, portraying all problems as caused by enemies of socialism, then denying the experiment was real socialism.

Argues that true Socialism is only ever seen the utopia it hopes to be, rather than a means of structuring society which appears to demonstrate repeated weaknesses.

Since it is trying to expose a pattern, each chapter can feel similar and anyone with limited knowledge of socialist countries' histories (like me) will lack context but the book is about how socialism is perceived, not executed so this isnt the fault of the book. Just be aware.

Delivery is fine though the American pronunciation is wrong for a number of words and idioms by the British author. Annoying but no deal breaker.

Good listen, recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Amazing book perfect for our time

What an insightful and interesting narrative. While slightly repetitive, it is entertaining and hugely topical. Needs to be more celebrated and well known.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

it's interesting, but long

It's a very long book, due to the fact it goes round and round in circles.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good book, bad narration.

The book gives a fair and thorough overview of the history of socialist regimes and why socialist ideology fails.
In my opinion it maybe dwels a bit too much on the western academic defenders of socialist regimes, but I that is perhaps to be expected given the thesis the book seeks to prove. It is fair, gives good arguments, is not overly academic while not talking down to the listener, and does not try to be sensational in its narrative.
A criticism I have to give is the narration though. The thick American accent does not fit a book whiten by a Brit, and he absolutely butchers every single foreign word or name in the book. It frankly becomes a bit distracting, and it is obvious that he has not even bothered to look up the pronunciation of the words he struggles to pronounce. Please find someone who at least can pronounce "Jacobin" correctly next time.
I can recommend the book despite that, and I highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in ideology.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Provocative and game changing

This was such an eye opener for someone like me armed with preconceptions and biases towards socialism yet over recent years wondering why high profile contemporary supporters of socialist regimes nearly always appeared to deny post hoc that those same regimes were not in fact socialist. Challenge those biases and listen to this superbly written and most importantly exhaustively researched book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Accessible and relatable

Many of us who lived behind the iron curtain and managed to escape (and family who stayed behind and saw the system fall) never quite understand how those in free nations could venerate the ideologies that lead to such horrific and repressive systems. Kristian does a great job articulating how the privileged of the West can idealise abstract ideologies while simultaneously distancing themselves from the inevitable/inbuilt real-world harms and authoritarian consequences of their implementation. Good job, easy read and very relatable.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

several cautionary tales for the comrades.

A no holds barred trip around all our favourite totalitarian states, and yes it still doesn't work.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful