Well written and original

Interesting story that defies expectation. Central character has a unique voice. The prose style is direct, concise, and easy to listen to.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A lot of really good themes, but...

This book started off so well, the initial build up to the main theme and story line was do promising, but it tailed off massively... very disappointing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Voice problems

The reader's voice was problematic - I had to borrow the book to find that Patcher was Patra. Patra and Paul were both fey creatures, but to match their voice with the whole book made it hard to follow. My own fault, I so much wanted to hear this I didn't download a sample.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Intriguing but confusing

Beautifully read, Gorgeous, evocative prose with one fairly shocking story at its core. All a bit confusing with the switches between places ans time periods. The first person narrative meant that a 15 year old girl was given a great deal of insight into her own and other’s behaviours, with only a couple of striking moments where others described her. I’m left feeling that although I couldn’t understand the relevance of some of the stories within this, the whole was actually greater than the sum of its parts.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Confusing switch between irrelevant time periods

difficult read but was very drawn in at the beginning. after halfway the time periods started to switch, which usually adds more depth to a story, but it made following the storylines confusing and some areas didn't seem to add any value. nothing added up at the end, the last chapter doesn't fit with the rest of the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

If only something would have happened

This book suffers from revealing its hand too early, then failing to make the interim interesting or having enough to say about its biggest topic. Instead a listless narrator of little depth fails to see something, then fails to have the capacity to help us explore it in any useful depth. A shame.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An absorbing novel, with hidden depths.

At a very basic level this novel seems very simple, a tale of a young girl growing up in an unusual environment ( an ex-commune) who becomes attracted to the life of a seemingly ordinary family who live nearby. She becomes drawn in by that family and becomes implicated in the secrets that bind them. It all ends in tragedy and the girl has to examine her part in it.

But this novel is so much more than that straightforward narrative. It examines bullying in all its forms, by adults and children; secrets and lies; the nature of truth; coercion within relationships; religion and the choices that it forces upon vulnerable people; the rights of children; alleged paedophiles and their 'victims'.

It is very atmospheric and the descriptions of the remote area in which the story is set are very vivid. The only thing that bothered me was the voice of the narrator. Someone with a little more gravitas would have been more suitable, I felt. but overall, it didn't spoil the story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Fine narration, dull story

The story was drawn out and I found it rather tedious. Protagonist not very likeable and not interesting enough. Would have benefited from a good merciless editor who'd cut out half of the heroine's inner monologue/emotions.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Compelling and rather odd

History of Wolves is a coming of age story that will resonate with many people. Linda, mostly left to raise herself by hippy, laid back parents, lives in Northern Minnesota, on grounds that used to belong to a commune, of which her parents were members.

Linda is 14, melodramatic and poetic. She's somewhat obsessed with a classmate, Lily, who spread rumours that their teacher, Me Grierson, molested her though this is questionable. Linda's narrative often veers off into dark corners, and the way the story is told (going back and forth, from teenage Linda to older Linda, reminiscing) only serves to increase the feeling of unease as the reader continues through the story.

The girl also spends a lot of time babysitting Paul, a toddler who moved into a cabin across the lake with his mother, Patra. Paul's father, Leo, is often working away, but when he arrives, Linda's relationship with Petra becomes strained. Patra's youth becomes glaringly obvious when her older husband appears. As a reader you're aware that something terrible has happened, but author Emily Fridlund trickled the information into your mind, keeping you reading until the end. The story surrounds Linda feeling both as a victim and a wrongdoer.

It's not the best Man Booker long list read as at times the narrative is far too disjointed. But the author writes very well.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Good but Bloopers

I found this dark coming-of-age story extremely compelling and it has more emotional resonance for me than anything else on the Booker shortlist this year. Caitlin Thorburn read very well, although the voice was a little teenagy for a woman in her 30's as Madeline is when she narrates the story.

What annoyed me though were the bloopers, when a word was misread and became non-sensical in the context of the sentence - there were quite a few and they were majorly jarring and pulled me out of the story each time. How hard would it be to stop the recording and rerecord that section and get it right? This is a question for all publishers of audiobooks.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

10 people found this helpful