Excellent and well detailed.

Fascinating listen, it could have been so different. Dunkirk was sold as a triumph, the German version somewhat different. Well worth a read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Brilliantly Balanced

At last, full credit given to the Belgian and French Armed Forces in a disaster caused by the naive foolishness of Belgian & Dutch neutrality, the grand error of the Dyle "Plan" and the total absence of Allied leadership & coordination in the face of radical new Wehrmacht methods of breakthrough!
Full credit to the RAF too.
Above all, we get a full explanation of the military context for the "Stand Still Order". The successful evacuation of 338,000 troops by sea was after all exceedingly far-fetched & the depleted Panzer Divisions were needed down South.
The experiences of the soldiers at all levels during the whole campaign leading to Dunkirk is also fully & brilliantly reflected.
Puts the Dunkirk Films (even the excellent 1958 one) firmly in the shade for facts and context.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An Exciting and Tragic Story

The narration is faultless and the story gripping. The book is superbly well written and extremely well researched. It is also humane, balanced and precise. Very enjoyable but also tragic - such a waste of human life and resources, for what end?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A very clear truth of the Dunkirk withdrawal

Loved this book. I've always thought that he French just surrendered at Dunkirk. How wrong have I been. The northern French army fought a tremendous battle to keep German forces at bay, right until the end.
The British army as always fought brilliantly, and being one of the smaller armies did tremendously well under the circumstances.
I have been utterly engrossed in this audio book, and got my map of northern France out to see the whole area of battle.
One thing that has always puzzled me though is that the French army was superior in every way to Germany, even their ranks could putting the Panzer 4 German workhorse, and there is little mention of the French air force being used at Dunkirk.
I know it is now history, but this historic defeat of France and Great Britain, tells a sad truth that you must be prepared to confront 'Willie's of which Germany at that time was the biggest and most dangerous.
Great narration throughout this audio book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Different and interesting

Different side of the evacuation of Dunkirk as someone who has grown up with the British story of Dunkirk ,to see how the Germans saw and viewed this was interesting

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good, interesting, innovative

I have read more than a dozen of Dunkirk "stories" and seen some films - all were produced by the allies side. It's a bit different, so it is a real added value to the whole Dunkirk story. I have more respect for French performance in 1940 campaign now and it was also interesting to learn about Germans thinking when they were at the top of their conquests. I highly recommend this audiobook.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

both sides

This was a really good listen as there was input from all the nations involved...

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Detailed account

Interesting facts and very detailed account of the confusion and luck around the BEF evacuation

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Dunkirk, a different perspective

All previous information about the ‘miracle’of Dunkirk has heavily been about the evacuation from Dunkirk from a British perspective. The book draws heavily on how the Germans conducted their campaign to crush the BEF, French and Belgian armies. It gives credit to the French forces who contributed greatly to the embarkations through their fighting retreat alongside their British allies. The Belgians stood shoulder to shoulder with their allies until their Government surrendered.
It is very well written and narrated, I thoroughly recommend it. Lots of interesting facts not the least being that there is a comparative lack of German sources because so many of the German soldiers that took part in the campaign were sent to the Eastern Front in 1941 and did not survive. The British evacuees did not have to endure that disaster and it bought time to rebuild the army for later campaigns

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

German perspective?

I have regularly wondered while listening to this book as to whether I have downloaded the wrong book by mistake. It does have some of the German perspective, but I would say that the vast majority of it seemed to be the British perspective.

I wanted to listen to this as I was really blown away by D-day through German eyes, which was just fascinating. I also loved Waterloo by Tim Clayton who was very effective at hammering home the message that really the Prussians won Waterloo, at least that's what I took from it.

I wouldn't say this was anything like either of those, in that it didn't have those incredibly candid and uncomfortable perspectives revealed in D-day through German eyes nor was it as exhaustingly gripping as Waterloo by Tim Clayton.

For me this was a solid history book, mainly from the British perspective. The postscript does reveal the reasons for this, namely the scarcity of the German sources. In many respects I thought that the postscript was the best bit, it certainly seemed to be the most coherent attempt to establish what the German perspective really was and delve more into the context of the battle for the rest of the war. It's just a shame that the rest of the book wasn't much more like that, if it were to deliver on the title at least.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful