Admirable and impressive but hard to care about

It’s brilliantly written and I found the character of Sadie interesting and well drawn. But overall it felt more like a demonstration of research than a novel so I learned stuff but didn’t feel or care much.
This fit the character but, on top of the very detailed, slow story, made for near boredom on occasion.
I also had very mixed feelings about the narration.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Creative writing

I found this very difficult and wasn’t keen on the narrator/author. There’s no doubt the writing is brilliant but I don’t think it transfers well to audible. I will read the book some time. This could win the Booker 2024

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

I don’t get it

Why is this book so hyped up? I loved the mars room but this no thanks. Im surprised it’s short listed

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Thin cliches and stereotypes

Highly annoying protagonist who has little depth and little character development. Some clever ploys but all in all she has written much better books and with a town out there to read, why waste your time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Wonderful

Great story and characters. Funny and moving. Love to hear Rachel reading too. Can’t wait to read and listen to her next book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Interesting book terrible narration

I guess the author should be able to narrate their work but this was almost impossible to listen to. So monotonous and no differentiation between the voices of different characters. I can see why the book has been critically acclaimed but I wish I’d read it instead of listened.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

intelligence Ain't Everything

Intelligence is a weapon, and Sadie knows how to employ it with cold precision and an air of superiority. Intellectual superiority is a theme in this strange soup of a book, which left me feeling like a fish on a hook from the lake that Sadie spends time at while she infiltrates a French environmental activist commune, finding her way into people's heads and beds, whilst pursuing her own agendas. I am all for a calculating and ruthless female protagonist but Sadie is detached and in many ways devoid, filling her time manipulating almost anyone and everyone.

Her only real fixation is on an aged and mysterious activist named Bruno who she only knows via a hacked email account. His treatises on the truth of the neanderthal, histories on ancient civilisations and our western assumptions of superiority are peppered like university lectures throughout the novel, and informs Sadie's framing of her own story, feeding the intellectual curiosity that is required to outsmart, snare and convince her prey, and to justify and position herself, to set her above the mileu she is ensconced with.

It's a lovely unrequited affair of sorts, as Sadie critically evaluates her world in relation to Bruno and his acolytes, an empty vessel shuffling through philosophy and experiences seemingly looking for existential meaning that elevates a life that casts all this aside at a whim.

A very beautifully described but slow thriller (not too many thrills) that almost languishes in its self-reflective athletics. Sometimes intellectual curiosity can feel a chore, and this elevated spy story , like Sadie herself feels just a bit too self-satisfied in its superiority.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

speed up narration

The book itself is extraordinary. The narration nearly killed it. It is so monotonous and slow. I found myself wondering if it was AI and if not, had the narrator even read the book. I couldn't believe it when I spotted that the narration was by the author.

At 1.3x speed, the narration was tolerable, and I did make it to the end. It's a beautiful and amazing book, that deserves a better recording.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not for me

I DNFd this. I kept waiting for something to happen and got so bored, I couldn’t give it the time or patience any longer. A very frustrating read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Don’t get the audible version

The writing and concepts are interesting, but I don’t think I can get past the first couple of hours because of the delivery. It’s such a monotone drawl that I presumed it was AI generated, but I think recent AI would make a much better job. Please listen the sample first.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!