One of my favourites

Forget all the other reviews on here the narration is fine. Not quite as good as Julian Rhind-Tut who did a couple of Hornby books but it’s good enough.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

good book

I listened to this at work I did enjoy it and made the day past quicker

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Russell Tovey fails to ruin an outstanding book...

Any additional comments?

... but he does come close.

His Rob is good (it took a little while to get used to, as I adore both the book and the film and they're all jumbled up in my mind having read and seen them 5+ times each) if perhaps sounding a little too much like Russell Tovey himself rather than the character. His team at Championship Vinyl are also good, although Barry is overdone meaning that his first line of "Twist and Shout" in the last chapter is horribly incongruous with the following "and Barry can SING".

Yet like the unfortunate minority of narrators - but the majority of the ones I didn't like - he can't do the voices of the opposite gender well. Laura doesn't sound that different from Rob, and Marie sounds exactly like my mental image of an overenthusiastic drag queen, which almost made me give up on the audiobook.

Of course, High Fidelity has the singular honour of simultaneously being positioned in both my top 5 books and my top 5 films ever since I first read it at about 13/14 and saw it when I was 15/16, so I was never going to go easy on a narrator. That also means that there was never a chance of me giving the story anything less than a full five-star rating, and I think I might even have enjoyed the story - my first time re-encountering it in my 30s - even more than I did in my teens or twenties.

But Russell Tovey was wrong, oh so horribly wrong, as a choice for narrator, and while I've flickered between 2 stars and 3 for the narration, I didn't give up on it and enjoyed the story - with occasion cringes, especially as the vocalisation of Barry and Marie - to the end. It's a 2.5 star narration, rounded to 3 for audible, and sadly brings the 5 star story down to a 4-star rating overall.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Man behaving badly, naked and vulnerable

Along with Fever Pitch and About a Boy. High Fidelity forms a trilogy of late 20th century masculinity or lack of same. A must for every man, to laugh and cry at himself, and for every woman, so as to run away as fast as possible... or get one as a pet.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Simply great

After the abusive treatment this book got in the movies I didn’t have much hope for the Audible version. But it is brilliantly narrated and feels authentic to North London where I grew up. My personal favourite Hornby novel, so I admit bias. An in depth and unfashionably sympathetic delve into the male psyche. It is often not a pretty place to look, but it is real.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Bliss

One of my all time favourite films (yes it's one on my list) and I feel quite ashamed that I have only just got round to the book. It was mesmerising, a treasure in my collection and one I will listen to again and again.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

A modern classic

Really enjoyed this book, although I am a huge fan of the film, it's not often that a film is as good as the book, but in this case they are both brilliant. Nick really gets you deep into the psychosis of a/ 35yr old single man!

Russel Tovey does a great job narrating, even if he does sound like Jack Dee occasionally!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Possibly my favourite novel of all time

I used to listen to the abridged version of this and it was read by Nigel Planer. It was the best narration of a book ever. Tovey is decent as a narrator and definitely grows into it. The first few minutes are oddly stilted. But it’s hard to hear a different voice reading it. The book itself is superb, definitely in my top five novels of the 90s. I’ve got the list written down somewhere …

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

High Fidelity Twenty (One) Years On

I own the paperback of this dating back to the mid 90s when it formed part of the "New Lad" zeitgeist. Although I have now read it at least twice, I thought that I'd give the audiobook version a whirl.

So, the plot: thirty something Rob Fleming, owner of an independent record Shop called 'Championship Vinyl' in Archway, North London, teaches a crunch point on his life when his live-in girlfriend, lawyer Laura leaves him. Cue, heartbreak, introspection and a whole load of 'top 5' lists in that typically male autistic way.

Russell Tovey is an appalling narrator; the worst I'd heard so far in my experience of Audible titles. He places pauses in the wrong places, his vocal cadence is all over the place and he's got a grating tone. I therefore will be avoiding all other titles narrated by him.

Warning: there's a fair amount of swearing in this book, more than I recall really. It's worth noting if you're playing the title out loud at home.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

11 people found this helpful

love

I love the book and the film, surprisingly one being American and one British is great because they're similar but different so neither is better

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!