Recording / Mixing music

Amazing documentation of recording and mixing music from the sixties right up until the present day.

A must listen for any body who loves listening to the sound of a great record.

Phil Brown is a bonafide guy who walked and danced through the world of the recording studio and is still rolling.

God bless

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Endearingly ordinary

I don't want to say too many negative things about this book because the author has clearly put so much of himself into it, and anyway, it's a kind of celebration of modest achievements by an average guy in his field. I thought there would be lots about the big names such as Hendrix, Led Zepplin, the Rolling Stones, but the author didn't have much to say about them because his contact with them was very limited. So you get some minor work with these major artists and a lot of major work with relatively minor artists.
The author gives far too much information about the equipment he's using, and spends too long detailing the precise process of making an album, and this can be really rather tedious for the average reader. Mr Brown is very often of the opinion that the albums he has worked on are great, but this is rarely reflected in sales. Released at the wrong time, not given a lot of publicity, not given any airplay, legal wrangles with the record company etc are the reasons he comes up with, but I suspect the quality of material is the real culprit. I haven't heard of most of the bands he mentions, let alone individual musicians, and when I looked through the 20,000 songs in my collection only one is by Murray Hedd (one night in Bangkok, from the musical chess), and only one by Robert Palmer (the brilliant addicted to Love). But the author spends chapter after chapter describing his experiences with these two artists. Ah well... You also start to feel a bit sorry for him because you know that this great project he is currently involved in is going to come to nothing in the end, or will be beset by difficulties. It never quite works out. But that's what's so endearing about the book. You understand how he feels and you see how things happen in his business. And in his life. And you feel for him, because, after all, he's just an ordinary guy like you.
He tries hard, he seems like a nice guy, but I suspect that he, like the book, would get a grade of C+. not in the top rank, might get a B on a good day, Will certainlyget a few B minuses, but mainly it's C+
I'm assuming that the reader, Terry Brown, is Phill's brother. For some reason, I found Terry's inhalations of breath very noisy and intrusive, hence the rather low scores

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

An excellent tale, brilliantly told...

I should probably start this review by mentioning that I am a musician and have my own purpose-built recording studio in my garden, where I spend many a happy hour. When I saw that this title was available I snapped it up, and I must say it does not disappoint.

There’s a phrase in music that says ‘To work as a studio recording engineer, start as a Tea-Boy and work your way down’, and that’s exactly what author Phill Brown does, starting out as a general assistant, setting up mics and preparing reels of tape, and in very little time he finds himself assisting on recording sessions for the major stars of the day, with his working week being about as diverse as it could be, with The Rolling Stones one day, Anita Harris the next, and The Small Faces the next.

As the years roll by Brown’s CV grows to read like a who’s who of modern music world. Hendrix, Bob Marley, King Crimson, Roxy Music, Robert Palmer, Talk-Talk, the list just goes on and on, and Phill Brown’s first-hand experience and observations offer a whole new insight into the reality behind the gloss of the music industry. I especially liked that he engineered for many of the lesser-known bands that I grew up with (The excellent Ace, and Hustler for example). Hearing his stories on the arduous process of recording and the stories behind the music has also re-united me with artists I’ve not listened to for a while, such as John Martyn, as well as introducing me to acts I’d missed the first time around like Talk-Talk.

It’s also very interesting to hear Brown’s observations on the continuous changes to the music industry, with the advent of the digital technology during the 80s driving a complete change to the way music was recorded and produced, to the ever-growing presence and interference of the men-in-suits during the recording process.

Ironically the only minor bugbear I found was that the overall quality of the recording is not as good as other books I’ve listened to, and sounds rather like Brown recorded this himself at home. This is understandable given his profession, but there are some rather dodgy edits where the narration suddenly jumps. In Chapter 15, where we find the author in hospital, the narrator seems to lose his way before noisily clearing his throat and carrying on at a different part of the story.

But these are minor irritations; the overall title is excellent and will definitely worth a second listen.

If you are in any way interested in Pop Music, you are gonna love this!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Fascinating listen

Loved hearing about Phil’s career. I knew of his work with Talk Talk , amazing. I’m now going to listen to the music that he talks about in the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fantastic

Really enjoyable stuff. A window on a vanishing world with all of what it means to be in and around music. Highly recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

good book errors in narration

book story is great, however there are points in the recording where narrator has made a mistake or coughed and this has not been corrected or edited out, also some of his pronunciation leaves a little to be desired!! Despite that still very enjoyable

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Very inspiring

I thought it would drag but once I got used to this peculiar way of storytelling, I got really pulled in. All along,I would go back to all those records mentioned along the way. What a trip! Very inspiring!!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A bit of a yawn

What disappointed you about Are We Still Rolling??

I just didn't get into it at all. A very unexciting listen and not put over very well.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Here we go again. More drugs and debauchery. Doesn't anyone do anything else? Don't answer that.

I am at the point of writing about four hours or so in to this book and it's just the same as any other high profile music book. Drugs and not much else. Technical if you like that sort of thing but a layman would never understand half of it especially with the way it's read. I don't know if Terry brown is suffering from the long term effects of being stoned out of his head (none of them appear to have brains) or if it's jsut age. Family loyalty is all very well but really? Why didn't Phil Brown get somebody else to read it? anyway once you've read one junky's account of drugs you've read them all and this one is no different. It's jsut about a different set of junkies that's all. Did anyone have any sense back in the sixties? It seems not.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!