very good.

My only criticism would be that the reader can at times be a bit monotone. To some this may be relaxing and have an appeal to it but personally it can make it hard to listen for extended periods (3hours and beyond) in one sitting.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Long introduction, poor pronunciation

As other reviewers have mentioned, there is a very long introduction for what is essentially quite a short primary text. I found the audio levels much lower than some other Audible titles and therefore found it hard to hear over some background noise. The pronunciation is a bit squiffy at times. The introduction is quite dry and academic but does put the work in its intellectual context. It didn’t exactly make we want to storm the barricades, although I did advocate for better pay and conditions for Deliveroo drivers while reading it!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good - if you like long intros.

This must be the only audiobook where the first three-quarters are taken up with people talking about the book rather than reading the book itself. The narrator is good however.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

This is not the actual Communist Manifesto. Don’t make the same mistake I did

This is not the actual Communist Manifesto. Don’t make the same mistake I did. It’s just about okay for what it is but I don’t really see the value

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

80% not the Communist Manifesto!

Unfortunately, despite the authors being listed as Marx and Engels this is not true and the majority of this book is a written commentary of the Communist Manifesto. misleading!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The Marxist view of history

‘The Communist Manifesto’ itself, hastily published during the initial weeks of the 1848 revolution in France, is a short work which, on its own, requires under two hours to narrate. This Penguin edition contains a very useful introduction to the work, more than three times the length of the work itself, detailing the background to the Manifesto; the conditions which brought it about; its initial and later reception; the influences upon the thought of Engels and Marx; a consideration of the respective contributions of Engels and of Marx to the work; and a consideration of the question of why, in the work, Marx praised so highly the achievements of the bourgeoisie up to his time.

The text of the work is the Samuel Moore translation of the second German edition of 1872 for the first English edition of 1888. For a nineteenth-century translation this still sounds strikingly modern, and therefore perfectly serviceable. It also has the advantages of being the translation which has had the greatest influence on the English-speaking world, and of having received the imprimatur of Engels himself.

The Manifesto is awash with memorable phrases, from the opening line, “A spectre is haunting Europe: the spectre of Communism,” to its closing demand, “Working men of all countries, unite!” It is also a document filled with bile against the bourgeoisie, a term which Marx and Engels employ as a generic object of hatred representing every form of modern oppression which must be forcibly overthrown by revolution. In this, the work comes across as rather simplistic, casually ironing out the multifarious tides and movements of history, and allowing no recognition to historical motivations to social change other than class struggle, such as, e.g., the Christian awakenings seen in the Reformation or in the anti-slavery movement. From such simplification of human history arose so much of what subsequently occurred in the twentieth century.

Narration

The choice of narrator for this audio edition is bizarre. Arinze Kene frequently mispronounces words (his “lassez-faire” [sic] and “hegemony” with a hard ‘g’ being two examples), and I was frequently annoyed by his inability to pronounce correctly the various French, German and Latin phrases which crop up particularly in the introduction.

Worse than this, however, is the pace of delivery, or rather lack of it. As a listener you want the narration to ebb and flow with the natural flow of the text; whereas Kene delivers this at a sort of flat pace which makes both introduction and Manifesto much harder to follow than they need be. It feels like he doesn’t understand what he’s reading: at one point in the Manifesto (25’ from the end of the audiobook) he reads, “a class is being developed which is destined to cut up root and branch the old order of society,” as if ‘root’ were the object of ‘cut up,’ and ‘branch’ were the succeeding verb.

He also, on three occasions (viz., in Chapter 4, 6º16’ from the end of the recording; in Chapter 9, 3º26’ from the end; and in the Manifesto itself, 1º04’ from the end), repeats an entire sentence or part of a sentence, without appearing aware of having done so.

It’s a great pity that the narration is so poor. It ruins what would otherwise be a very worthwhile audiobook.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Biased text by Gareth Stedman Jones

It's rather misleading that Engels and Marx are listed as the authors of this book, considering the communist manifesto takes up only 1 and a half hour of this 7 and a half hour long audio book.
Before you get to hear Marx and Engels text, you need to listen to 6 hours of biased arguments and postulates by Gareth Stedman Jones. He is not at all objective in his explanation, and so I would recommend you read the manifesto somewhere else.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

34 people found this helpful